Feb 8, 2011

Posted by in Featured, News | 14 Comments

Crew Skills Q&A With Damion Schubert

Crew Skills are BioWare’s implementation for harvesting and crafting in Star Wars™: The Old Republic™, but they’re really much more than that. From off-line crafting to diplomacy missions – not to mention companions who can do most of the work for you – this system is unlike any that you’ve seen in other MMORPGs.

Recently, Damion Schubert, Lead Systems Designer for Star Wars™: The Old Republic™ was nice enough to take some time for a little Crew Skills Q&A with Ask A Jedi to help expand our understanding of the system!

Ask A Jedi: How and when is the player first introduced to Crew Skills? Is it via narrative, or visiting a trainer at a certain level?

Damion Schubert: The Crew Skills trainers all like to hang out on the capital worlds, where the player can encounter them.  Each trainer will give the player a description of the Crew Skill they teach, along with the benefits they provide, so the player knows which Crew Skills may be most beneficial to their play style.

Ask A Jedi: How are the various Crew Skills Missions obtained? For example, are they auto-populated? Found in the wild? NPC Trainer? All of the above?

Damion Schubert: Most Crew Skills missions are drawn from a random pool for the player to choose from, and that pool refreshes from time to time.  However, some missions are unlocked by rare objects you might find in the world.  These missions are one-off, but tend to offer more substantial rewards.

Time to get busy.

Time to get busy.

Ask A Jedi: Artifice is one of the revealed Crafting skills, and is mentioned as the production of Jedi and Sith artifacts. Is this Crafting skill available only to Force users? Are any other Crew Skills limited to certain classes?

Damion Schubert: Nope!  There are no limits in that regard. It is the player’s call as to whether they want to choose a skill that might not be directly beneficial to their character.

Ask A Jedi: Will companion Crew Skill bonuses be unique per companion?

Damion Schubert: Each Companion has Crew Skills that are unique to that companion, designed to help create a little flavor for what that companion is all about.  However, these benefits are fairly minor – we don’t want you to leave a companion on the ship that you’d really like to take out, just because they have a crafting bonus.

Ask A Jedi: Is there a risk to your companions while on Missions? Can they die? In other words, what are the downsides of sending a companion on a mission?

Damion Schubert: They don’t die but they can fail, which means that the player will lose his initial capital investment (i.e. his credits and time spent).  It is up to the player to decide if he wants to play it safe with his companion missions, or go for higher risk, higher reward missions.  We have some ideas on how to expand this in the future.

Diplomatic Missions

Diplomatic Missions

Ask A Jedi: Are there mechanics in place that allow for crafting an item of better “quality” from the same recipe? For example, with additional or more rare materials?

Damion Schubert: Yes and at the same time, no – but we’re not ready to spill the beans yet on what that means, sorry! Trust me when I say we still have a few surprises to spring on the crafting community, once we prove the features are fun in the Game Testing Program.

Editor’s Note: We would like to help you prove those things in the Game Testing Program :)

Ask A Jedi: When gathering with your player character or with your active companion, do you physically need to take the resources back to your ship in order to use them in crafting? Does the ship have a “stock room” to hold these items for crafting?

Damion Schubert: Currently, items craft from and drop to your inventory.  This may change based on feedback from Game Testing and as we iterate on the system, though.

Ask A Jedi: Another concern regarding missions that might award dark or light side points is that it trivializes the morality system, essentially allowing you to “grind morality.” How is this system intended to work?

Damion Schubert: The system is less designed to allow you to ‘grind’ morality than it is to allow you to correct some bad decisions – which is fairly vital in an MMORPG, where you have no reload button.  It would take a pretty hefty time and cash investment to use this system to ‘grind’ morality.

Ah, the spoils.

Ah, the spoils.

Ask A Jedi: When sending companions out on missions, can you send them to locations you havenʼt been yet? Or bring back materials youʼve never found yourself before?

Damion Schubert: Yes and yes.  In fact, one of the key benefits of the missions system is to find rare crafting materials that aren’t ‘drops’ elsewhere in the world, usually used for making very high quality items.

Ask A Jedi: In the context of master crafters, “dedication” is cited as the avenue to achieve this status. Is it “time” that will allow you to become this elite crafter, or will there be rare resources, quests, raids (pve or pvp) or other activities that you need to do in order to achieve this status?

Damion Schubert: We want our top crafters to progress and get to be the best in their field by doing things that crafters like to do: research, gather very rare materials, and interact with other players as customers or resource suppliers.  We’re not a big fan of ‘you can be the best there is by staring at progress bars’, if for no other reason than then there is no way for great craftsmen to differentiate themselves from a casual craftsman with a lot of free time.

As for the other activities, we have some things we’ll be talking about eventually, but the general gist is that we want there to be a symbiotic relationship.  We want top-end raiders and PvPers to need crafters, but we want the crafters to need them in return.  And we’re trying to keep away from making anyone play a game they don’t want to play.  We want crafters to be primarily playing a social game, not spending hours doing stuff they don’t want to do.

Ask A Jedi: Itʼs been stated (by you in fact, on the forums,) that Crew Skills will not be the method players use for creating light sabers. Will there be an equivalent non-crafting “weapon” system for non-Force users?

Damion Schubert: Guns and vibroblades are made via a Crew Skill.  However, they are also ripe for… well, let’s just call it tinkering for now, and promise to tell you more at some point.

You guys keep working while I'm at dinner.

You guys keep working while I'm at dinner.

Ask A Jedi: With so much of this activity centralized on your ship, what is being done to assure that player hubs/cities are still filled with players, making them feel vibrant and alive?

Damion Schubert: Just because the activity is happening on your ship doesn’t mean that the player has to be there – he can direct his companion characters on his ship to craft while he is out adventuring, exploring, or socializing in the cities.  We anticipate most of our hardcore crafters will actually spend most of their time in the cities, where they can reach their customer base, engage in person to person transactions, or put their items up for sale – but then that’s another feature discussion for another day.

We just wanted to say thanks again to Damion for taking the time to answer these questions for our readers, and we cannot wait to hear more about the Crew Skills system in Star Wars™: The Old Republic™.

  1. I am still very excited about this system and can not wait until I can get my hands on it and the game. But alas, I will be playing Rift until The Holy Grail that is the Old Republic launches.

    • Completely looking forward to this new and original style of companion crafting. I remember in SWG I had a huge mining company. Although, I had made millions in credits…I never played the game….I was always filling orders for customers. It’s gonna be an excellent system and I can go play for once lol.

  2. Nice job, guys. I am looking forward to a different and new type of crafting experience.

  3. Nice info, thanks guys.
    I can’t wait to try this out in the game.

  4. Nice questions and answers. Not alot of news though, everything is still “not talked about”

    Hope they make a storage area on our ships, where everything will be stores instead of using the inventory.

    • Ya I am hoping for some sort of storage as well. Even if it is finite in nature. That would mean there would need to be prudent planning done with regard to mats for crafting. Also that is why they invented a bank system too to handle inventory overflow. It will be interesting to see how they handle it all.

      • SteppinRazor says:

        It actually was interesting today to see how they did handle it all, ships have cargo holds with massive storage space.

  5. great interview, couple of juicy tidbits there to speculate on.

    I honestly hope they have testers in there going over this system that actually have crafting knowledge and know how, it scares me to think of the kind of tester that may have their hands all over my system!

    *will test for food*

  6. TheDarkKnight says:

    Nice update there guys, keep up the good work :)

  7. ObiTinKenobi says:

    “Ask A Jedi: Another concern regarding missions that might award dark or light side points is that it trivializes the morality system, essentially allowing you to “grind morality.” How is this system intended to work?

    Damion Schubert: The system is less designed to allow you to ‘grind’ morality than it is to allow you to correct some bad decisions – which is fairly vital in an MMORPG, where you have no reload button. It would take a pretty hefty time and cash investment to use this system to ‘grind’ morality.”

    This has me slightly worried. I really like the flavor of diplomacy but if it is essentially an error correction tool, it sounds awfully difficult to balance.

    On the one hand I would hesitate to grab it fearing that if I take it over another skill, I will end up with a subpar character, since I could just not make any mistakes and then I’d have room for another skill. If I know that I am going full dark or full light, how hard can it be?

    On the other hand it might be a must-have, since it sounds like it could allow me to deliberately make opportunistic choices and then “correcting” their long term cost. Essentially a having-your-cake-and-eating-it-ability.

  8. WOW reading the time’s on those crafting screens does not fill me with joy, Sometimes when crafting for alt’s the last thing I want to do is wait 24 hours to make a pair of pants,a jumper, weapons of choice etc etc.

    Unless those time stamps are for gathering only, then that’d be a relief.

    • I am guessing that the things that take longer may not be simple things like pants or shoes… but I think they want to put an emphasis on the value of crafted items as more than just quick fixes for loot, and this would be a way to do that.

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Tweets that mention Crew Skills Q&A With Damion Schubert | Ask A Jedi -- Topsy.com - [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Hawk Silverthorn and Mos Eisley Radio, Ask A Jedi. Ask A Jedi …
  2. SWTOR fans ask whether Sith are evil and how Crew Skills work « Cyber Nation - [...] fan site AskAJedi.com was able to sit down with Lead Systems Designer Damion Schubert to talk about Crew Skills. …
  3. SWTOR fans ask whether Sith are evil and how Crew Skills work « Geek City - [...] fan site AskAJedi.com was able to sit down with Lead Systems Designer Damion Schubert to talk about Crew Skills. …
  4. SWTOR fans ask whether Sith are evil and how Crew Skills work « MMO City - [...] fan site AskAJedi.com was able to sit down with Lead Systems Designer Damion Schubert to talk about Crew Skills. …
  5. Ask A Jedi Talks With Damion Schubert About Crew Skills | TORWars - [...] can check out the interview in its entirety, here. [...]
  6. » SWTOR: Interview de Damion Schubert par Askajedi Taal-Children - [...] de tout ce que vous avez pu voir dans d’autres MMORPG. Découvrez-en plus grâce à cet article d’Ask A Jedi, …
  7. SWTOR: Interview de Damion Schubert par Askajedi | Taal-Children - [...] de tout ce que vous avez pu voir dans d’autres MMORPG. Découvrez-en plus grâce à cet article d’Ask A Jedi, …
  8. SWTOR.eu » SWTOR Crew-Skills – Interview bringt Neuigkeiten zum The Old Republic Crafting-System - [...] einem Interview auf askajedi.com verriet nun Lead Systems Designer  von The Old Republic Damion Schubert weitere Einzelheiten zu [...]
  9. Damion Schubert talks Crew Skills with Ask a Jedi - [...] More through the link [...]
  10. Star Wars: The Old Republic - Page 248 - Fires of Heaven Guild Message Board - [...] A little more on crew skills over at Ask a Jedi. While there are some aspects of the game …
  11. Episode #17: Roxanne vs. Godwin’s Law » Corellian Run Radio - [...] Schubert interview with Ask A Jedi.  Companions can’t be killed on missions, but they might screw it up and …
  12. What We Know ? » Star Wars The Old Republic Trader - [...] Currently any crafted items/resources just get placed in your standard inventory - AskAJedi [...]
  13. What We Know | How To Make Credits - [...] Currently any crafted items/resources just get placed in your standard inventory - AskAJedi [...]
  14. Damion Schubert talks Crew Skills with Ask A Jedi | Yufmelt.com - [...] out this great Q&A for yourself, please head over to the Ask A Jedi article which you can find …
  15. Latest information on Crew Skills | SWTOR Crew Skills - [...] Crew Skills Q&A With Damion Schubert – Source: Ask A Jedi [...]
  16. [Sammelthread] Star Wars - The Old Republic - Seite 48 - Forum de Luxx - [...] [...]
  17. The Game Mechanics of SWTOR Crafting Skills - [...] materials, because of the difficulty of normalising the items. There will however be a system for getting better results …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>